John Carpenter made great movies. Combined with David Cronenberg, the pair really seemed to nail the techno-phobia and weird societal shift that the 80s sometimes held onto. And “They Live” is a good example of this.
What other movie can you find ideas referenced — no, taken — by Shepard Fairey (“OBEY”), Evil 9 (their last album was called “They Live”) and Duke Nukem (“I came here to chew bubblegum and kick ass. And I’m all out of bubblegum.”*)?
But it’s based on a short story and the plot moves like it. For every great commentary on post-1980 life, class warfare, questioning societal norms, greed, technology issues and general trust issues, there is slow, plodding plot, flat dialogue, absurd fights and nonsensical story. The movie moves as if they only had 45 minutes worth of story, so they told Rowdy Roddy Piper to speak slowly and not do much, lest the story ends in less than the 90 minute run-time. How else to explain the entirely nonsensical 10 minute fight between him and his best friend in the middle of Act 2?**
But if you can overlook the flaws, the commentary the film makes is dead-on and still true today, perhaps more than ever.*** It doesn’t feel dated from that respect, which is slightly depressing. When Rachael and I looked at each other 20 minutes into the film and both said, “How aporopos to today,” something is going on. (Ok, fine, she said it, I was about to. We didn’t totally sync up our sentences by chance. But we were both thinking it.)
(And the use of B&W to show the view through the glasses was an excellent and well conceived art direction choice. Also, the PKE Meter appears in the film, used by the aliens, which made me laugh when I saw it.)
Final grade: B-
* Until I re-watched this, I thought the line was “I came here to kick ass and chew bubblegum.” But no, the two items are switched, sound worse in the movie and are actually delivered in the most lackluster way possible. It’s the kind of line that screams for a closeup and a gritty delivery. What you get is a long shot and a flat delivery.
** Wikipedia says that this 5.5 minute fight is a highlight of the film and took 3 weeks to rehearse. I’m calling bullshit on the first part; it felt like they just needed an excuse why Rawdy Roddy Piper was cast in the movie.
*** Last week’s Bill Meyer helped bear this out: much of the show was spent on discussing health care, the ‘threat’ of socialism. My favorite line? He asked when it became patriotic to care more about making a profit than the health of your fellow citizens. Bingo.
Popularity: 1% [?]
i’ve heard carpenter say the length of the fight scene was intentional as a metaphor to convey the difficulty of getting someone to see your point of view.
ben :: jul 31 2009 :: 4:05 pm